He pulled on one of her pigtails and pushed his nearly dry cock up her ass even further making Paige squeal and squirm.

“See? I told you a little eighteen-year-old slut like you couldn’t handle spit-lubed anal,” he said.

“I- I want it! Please! It’s my birthday! Fuck my ass like I’m a worthless whore! It’s my virginity and that’s how I want to lose it! Please, Mr. Smith!” she begged.

Mr. Smith sighed. He figured she’d pass out from the pain after a few strokes, but it was her birthday, so he didn’t have the heart to say no.

“Okay. Okay. Here comes an ass-fucking you’ll never forget,” he said and started thrusting in as deep and hard as he could.